Cover image
Quality Review Assessment Form

Thank you for your participation in the Discovery Stack Pilot study!


Please fill this form out AFTER providing in-line comments regarding the Quality of the manuscript using the hypothes.is application.


Use hypothes.is to denote the following on the manuscript pdf:

  • Note use of incorrect controls or statistical analyses.
  • Indicate conclusions that are not supported by the data.
  • Specify experiments where data quality is inadequate.
  • Denote if inappropriate experiments or analyses were used to address a question.
  • Provide experimental suggestions required to support conclusions.
  • Mark text that is not clear and/or suggestions for re-wording.


📝 After completing the Quality assessment of the manuscript, you will automatically be directed to a separate form to evaluate the Impact of the manuscript.


If you have any questions, comments, or suggestions, don't hesitate to email maureen.mcgargill@solvingfor.org.

Save and resume later